Professor Tal Danino Programs Bacteria to Destroy Cancer Cells
In a new paper published in Nature July 20, researchers programmed harmless strains of S. typhimurium bacteria to deliver toxic payloads. When deployed together with a traditional cancer drug, the bacteria shrank aggressive liver tumors in mice much more effectively than either treatment alone. The study was co-led by Tal Danino, assistant professor of biomedical engineering at Columbia Engineering, with colleagues at MIT and UC San Diego (UCSD).
“One of the early key steps to producing a bacteria drug-delivery vehicle was getting the bacteria to synchronize,” says Danino, who achieved this breakthrough in 2010 as a graduate student at UCSD. At the time, Danino designed a genetic circuit—a set of genes—that allowed bacteria to communicate and synchronize their behavior. The landmark work was published in Nature. (Video: http://daninolab.nyc/videos/2015/8/5/jlj51lvw8b4nrmkls11lmyicvk9rmn).
After earning his PhD at UCSD, Danino pursued a postdoctoral fellowship at MIT where he focused on finding applications of bacteria to detect and treat cancer. Working in Sangeeta Bhatia’s group at MIT’s Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research, Danino bridged the gap between his innovative synthetic biology research and health applications, specifically cancer. Now as director of the Synthetic Biological Systems Laboratory at Columbia Engineering, Danino is pushing forward on engineering bacteria therapies for cancer.
“While Tal was in Boston working with Sangeeta on probiotic bacteria, we were developing the population control circuit in the context of a biosensor,” says Jeff Hasty, a professor of bioengineering at UCSD. "We were showing Tal how bacterial populations could be designed to cycle and there was a eureka moment when it dawned on us that the same design could be used as a therapeutic.”
In this new study, the team exploits bacteria’s natural tendency to accumulate at disease sites. Certain strains of bacteria thrive in low-oxygen environments such as tumors, and suppression of the host’s immune system also creates favorable conditions for bacteria to flourish.
“Tumors can be friendly environments for bacteria to grow, and we’re taking advantage of that,” notes Sangeeta Bhatia, who is the John and Dorothy Wilson Professor of Health Sciences and Electrical Engineering and Computer Science at MIT and a member of MIT’s Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research and its Institute for Medical Engineering and Science.
Bhatia and Hasty are the senior authors of the paper. Lead authors are Danino and UCSD graduate student Omar Din.
The research team began looking into the possibility of harnessing bacteria to fight cancer several years ago. In a study published last year focusing on cancer diagnosis, the researchers engineered a strain of probiotic bacteria (similar to those found in yogurt) to express a genetic circuit that produces a luminescent signal, detectable with a simple urine test, if liver cancer is present.
These harmless strains of S. typhimurium, which can be either injected or consumed orally, tend to accumulate in the liver because one of the liver’s jobs is to filter bacteria out of the bloodstream.
In their new study, the researchers delivered artificial genetic circuits into the bacteria, that allow the microbes to kill cancer cells in three different ways. One circuit produces a molecule called hemolysin, which destroys tumor cells by damaging their cell membranes. Another produces a drug that induces the cell to undergo programmed suicide, and the third circuit releases a protein that stimulates the body’s immune system to attack the tumor.
To prevent potential side effects from these drugs, the researchers added another genetic circuit that allows the cells to detect how many other bacteria are in their environment, through a process known as quorum sensing. When the population reaches a predetermined target level, the bacterial cells self-destruct, releasing their toxic contents all at once. A few of the cells survive to begin the cycle again, which takes about 18 hours, allowing for repeated release of the drugs.
“That allows us to maintain the burden of the bacteria in the whole organism at a low level and to keep pumping the drugs only into the tumor,” Bhatia says.
The researchers tested the bacteria in mice with a very aggressive form of colon cancer that spreads to the liver. The bacteria accumulated in the liver and began their cycle of growth and drug release. On their own, they reduced tumor growth slightly, but when combined with the chemotherapy drug 5-fluorouracil, often used to treat liver cancer, they achieved a dramatic reduction in tumor size — much more extensive than if the drug was used on its own.
This approach is well suited to liver tumors because bacteria taken orally have high exposure there, Bhatia says. “If you want to treat tumors outside the gut or liver with this strategy, then you would need to give a higher dose, inject them directly into the tumor, or add additional homing strategies,” she says.
In previous studies, the researchers found that engineered bacteria that escape from the liver are effectively cleared by the immune system, and that they tend to thrive only in tumor environments, which should help to minimize any potential side effects.
Martin Fussenegger, a professor of biotechnology and bioengineering at ETH Zurich, calls the new approach “unconventional” and “highly promising.”
“This is a fascinating, refreshing, and beautiful concept,” says Fussenegger, who was not involved in the study. “In a world of mainstream cancer therapy concepts with often limited success, new therapy strategies are badly needed.”
The researchers are now working on programming the bacteria to deliver other types of lethal cargo. They also plan to investigate which combinations of bacterial strains and tumor-targeting circuits would be the most effective against different types of tumors.
“Our laboratory at Columbia Engineering,” notes Danino, who is also a member of Columbia’s Data Science Institute, “will be expanding upon several concepts developed in this publication in hopes of developing more effective bacterial therapies for cancer.”
The study was funded by the San Diego Center for Systems Biology, the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, the Ludwig Center for Molecular Oncology at MIT, an Amar G. Bose Research Grant, the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, a Koch Institute Support Grant from the National Cancer Institute, and a Core Center Grant from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences.